Menu of Pop's Uptown Supper Club in Antioch, Illinois, USA

Menu Overview

Pop's Uptown Supper Club, nestled in Antioch, Illinois, delivers a classic supper club experience with a contemporary touch. The menu is thoughtfully curated, showcasing a robust selection of hearty entrees and distinguished comfort foods that pay homage to supper club traditions while embracing modern palate preferences.

Signature dishes such as the Roasted Turkey Dinner and Meatloaf Dinner stand out for their generous portions and expertly balanced flavors, each priced reasonably at $22. Complementing these mains are perfectly crafted starters—soups and salads—that set a refined yet approachable tone for the meal. The relish tray, while a cherished tradition, could benefit from a bit more generosity, but its inclusion preserves the authentic supper club atmosphere.

Customer feedback highlights the quality of the core offerings: succulent ribs, prime rib, rack of lamb, and impeccable pork schnitzel have all received praise for being cooked to precise perfection, showcasing the kitchen’s command over diverse proteins. Desserts, particularly Pop's Famous Coconut Cream Pie and the delightfully airy beignets, round out the dining experience with sweet finesse. At $14, the coconut cream pie is a decadent indulgence that guests consistently enjoy.

The dining environment marries rustic charm with upscale ambiance. The interior’s elegant design contrasts pleasantly with the quaint, wooded exterior, offering a warm and inviting setting. Seating options include a quieter, semi-private northern room ideal for more intimate or relaxed gatherings. Attentive service spearheaded by personable waitstaff and approachable owners enhances the overall experience, contributing to an atmosphere where patrons feel valued and well-cared-for.

Pop’s also embraces the communal spirit of supper clubs, with a notable presence of owners actively engaging with guests, ensuring both service quality and guest satisfaction remain high. Drinks are crafted with an eye towards classic supper club traditions—highlighted by house-specialty ice cream cocktails that guests unanimously recommend.

While some reviews indicate occasional timing and pacing issues, especially on busy weekend nights, the food quality and atmosphere consistently earn high marks. Small details like water with an off-putting sulfur taste are rare outliers but worth noting as areas for improvement. The restaurant’s commitment to evolving the supper club model is evident, successfully bridging nostalgic charm with modern dining expectations.

In summary, Pop's Uptown Supper Club is a solid culinary destination for anyone seeking authentic supper club fare enriched by attentive service and a welcoming vibe. Whether savoring a perfectly cooked pork chop, indulging in a prime rib, or sharing the famed Coconut Cream Pie, diners can expect a satisfying and memorable experience reminiscent of classic Americana with a refined edge.